Pretty Little Liars actor Keegan Allen was left bloodied and bruised after being pistol-whipped and robbed outside a high-end grocery store in Los Angeles. The 37-year-old, who played Toby Cavanaugh on the hit show from 2010 to 2017, took to Instagram moments after he was set upon by two masked men outside the Laurel Supply store in West Hollywood on Thursday evening (October 8). Allen said one of them held him at knife-point while the other one struck him several times with a gun and stole his watch. He also posted surveillance footage of the attack.